When serial killer Arthur Shawcross learns that John Ehrlich, a reporter from his hometown, now lives in his new city of residence, Shawcross decides to allow Ehrlich his only interview on the anniversary of his first year in prison. Twenty years after hearing the name “Shawcross” as the child killer in his hometown, John Ehrlich finds himself sitting across from the man he believed was the true “boogie man” from his childhood. In his interview, Ehrlich confronts the mind of a serial killer and the unknown demon from his past.