Maddie and Tyler are best friends. Best friends mend each other’s wounds. But then Maddie and Tyler go to a party, and something happens to Maddie… and something happens to Tyler… and these wounds are ones they don’t know how to mend. So they run away to an abandoned fairground to play pretend under a rollercoaster for the rest of their days. But something’s watching Maddie. And Tyler can’t stop drinking. And all this role-playing kind of makes them feel like more than just friends?? A modern retelling of Peter Pan, let’s pretend asks us to consider: does growing up really mean forgetting?